Introduction – Best coffee shops in New York City’s Suburbs
Thinking about moving to the suburbs of New York City? You’re not alone. Many city dwellers are opting for suburban life, drawn by more space, better schools, and a quieter environment—all while staying within commuting distance of the Big Apple. If you’re a coffee lover, you might be wondering: where can I find great coffee outside NYC? Fortunately, suburban coffee culture is thriving. This guide will introduce you to the best coffee shops in New York City’s suburbs, helping you ease into your new home with a perfect cup of coffee.
Why Move to the Suburbs?
Relocating to the suburbs offers several benefits, including:
- Nature Access: Parks, hiking trails, and green spaces for outdoor lovers.
- Affordability: Lower cost of living compared to Manhattan and Brooklyn.
- More Space: Larger homes, backyards, and quieter streets.
- Great Schools: Access to top-rated public and private schools.
- Community Feel: A sense of belonging with local events and businesses.
Five Top Coffee Shops in NYC’s Suburbs
1. Boxwood Coffee – Summit, NJ
📍 Google Rating: 4.7 ⭐ | Yelp Rating: 4.5 ⭐
🌐 Website
Located in the charming town of Summit, Boxwood Coffee is known for its ethically sourced beans and meticulously brewed drinks. Whether you prefer a strong espresso or a creamy oat milk latte, their menu caters to all coffee enthusiasts. Plus, their cozy atmosphere makes it a perfect remote work spot.
🚆 Commute Time to NYC: 40 min to Penn Station via NJ Transit
Must-Try: Lavender Honey Latte & Almond Croissant
2. The Granola Bar – Westport, CT
📍 Google Rating: 4.6 ⭐ | Yelp Rating: 4.4 ⭐
🌐 Website
If you’re moving north of the city, The Granola Bar in Westport offers an excellent mix of artisanal coffee and wholesome breakfast options. Their stylish, modern decor and friendly staff make it a local favorite.
🚆 Commute Time to NYC: 1 hour to Grand Central via Metro-North
Must-Try: Iced Coconut Mocha & Avocado Toast
3. The Able Baker – Maplewood, NJ
📍 Google Rating: 4.8 ⭐ | Yelp Rating: 4.6 ⭐
🌐 Website
Maplewood’s suburban charm pairs perfectly with The Able Baker, a beloved local café known for its fresh-baked goods and premium coffee. The friendly neighborhood ambiance makes it an ideal weekend hangout.
🚆 Commute Time to NYC: 35 min to Penn Station via NJ Transit
Must-Try: Mocha Latte & Classic Chocolate Chip Cookie
4. Tusk & Cup – Ridgefield, CT
📍 Google Rating: 4.7 ⭐ | Yelp Rating: 4.5 ⭐
🌐 Website
Nestled in Ridgefield, Tusk & Cup is a hidden gem offering robust espresso and decadent pastries. They also feature locally roasted beans, ensuring fresh, high-quality brews.
🚆 Commute Time to NYC: 1 hour 20 min to Grand Central via Metro-North
Must-Try: Flat White & Cannoli
5. Rockin’ Joe – Caldwell, NJ
📍 Google Rating: 4.6 ⭐ | Yelp Rating: 4.3 ⭐
🌐 Website
For coffee lovers who appreciate a retro vibe, Rockin’ Joe in Caldwell is a must-visit. This rock music-themed coffeehouse serves expertly crafted espresso drinks and delicious pastries in a laid-back setting.
🚆 Commute Time to NYC: 45 min to Penn Station via NJ Transit
Must-Try: Caramel Macchiato & Blueberry Muffin
Suburban Coffee Culture vs. NYC Coffee Scene
While NYC is famous for its fast-paced coffee culture—where you grab a to-go cup and rush to the subway—suburban coffee shops focus on a slower, community-driven experience. Many suburban cafés prioritize locally roasted beans and sustainable practices. (Source: Specialty Coffee Association)
In contrast, NYC’s coffee scene offers an extensive variety but often at a premium due to higher rents. Suburban coffee shops, meanwhile, tend to be more affordable and encourage patrons to sit, relax, and connect with the local community. (Source: The New York Times)
Tips for Finding the Best Coffee Shops in Your New Suburb
- Try a Coffee Subscription: Many local cafes offer monthly coffee bean subscriptions. (Source: Forbes)
- Check Google & Yelp Reviews: Look for high ratings and recent reviews. (Source: Yelp)
- Visit Local Farmer’s Markets: Many small roasters sell their beans here. (Source: USDA Farmers Market Directory)
- Ask Locals: Neighborhood Facebook groups or Nextdoor forums can offer great suggestions. (Source: Nextdoor)

Photo of a stylish Coffee Shop with wooden tables and chairs, by Ruben Ramireza on Unsplash.com
Conclusion – The Best Coffee Shops in New York City’s Suburbs
Relocating from NYC to the suburbs doesn’t mean sacrificing great coffee. Whether you’re moving to New Jersey, Connecticut, or another nearby area, you’ll find excellent cafés ready to serve you a perfect cup. Looking for more moving tips? Check out CitiesToSuburbs.com.